Why Did NJ Homeowners Insurance Rates Increase?

New Jersey homeowners have seen steady increases in insurance premiums in recent years. Several factors and trends are driving these changes, making it more expensive to insure your home and property.

​

1. Rising Costs of Building Materials and Labor

​

One of the main reasons for increased premiums is the rising cost of construction materials and labor. If your home were damaged or destroyed, rebuilding costs would be significantly higher today than just a few years ago. Materials like lumber, steel, and concrete have all experienced price surges due to supply chain issues, inflation, and global demand.

​

2. Increased Weather-Related Risks

​

New Jersey’s location makes it particularly vulnerable to hurricanes, wind, and other severe storms. Events like Superstorm Sandy in 2012 and Hurricane Ida in 2021 highlighted the state’s susceptibility to extreme weather. As insurers account for these growing risks, premiums have increased to reflect the potential for more frequent and severe claims.

​

3. Inflation and Economic Conditions

​

Inflation impacts every sector, and the insurance industry is no exception. Higher costs of goods and services translate into larger claim payouts for insurers, who then adjust premiums to offset these expenses.

​

4. Higher Claims Frequency and Severity

​

The insurance industry in NJ has seen an increase in claims, both in frequency and severity. More claims lead to higher costs for insurers, which are then passed on to policyholders. This trend is especially notable in densely populated states like New Jersey.

 

Factors That Determine Your NJ Homeowners Insurance Premium

​

While overall rates are increasing, specific factors unique to your property and policy will also influence how much you pay.

​

1. Location of Your Home

​

If your home is in a severe storm, high wind area, or close to the coast, you’re likely paying a higher premium. Similarly, neighborhoods with higher crime rates or limited access to emergency services, such as fire hydrants 500 feet from your home or a local fire department within 5 miles, may see increased rates.

​

2. Age and Condition of Your Home

​

Older homes often cost more to insure because they may require specialized materials or craftsmanship to repair. Homes with outdated electrical, plumbing, or roofing systems may also pose a higher risk of damage.

​

3. Replacement Cost vs. Market Value

​

Insuring your home based on its replacement cost rather than its market value can increase premiums. However, this approach ensures you have sufficient coverage to rebuild your home entirely in the event of a loss.

​

There is often confusion when determining the cost to insure your home and comparing the market value vs. replacement cost.  It is critical that you have sufficient replacement cost coverage for your home to help rebuild it after a partial or total loss. Many of the factors determining the replacement cost of your home include:

​

• Cost of demolition and debris removal

• Cost of labor

• Cost of materials

• Architectural and contractor costs​

​

Our goal when determining replacement cost coverage is to ensure we can rebuild your home with the same like, kind, and quality of materials after a total or partial loss. 

​

4. Policy Customizations and Add-Ons

​

Optional coverages, such as flood insurance, high-value item coverage, or enhanced liability protection, will raise your premium. While these add-ons provide critical protection, they come at a cost.

 

What Homeowners Can Do to Manage Rising Insurance Costs

​

Rising insurance rates are a reality, but there are steps you can take to control your premiums while maintaining adequate protection for your home.

​

1. Shop Around for the Best Rates

​

Not all insurers calculate premiums the same way or have the same coverages or costs. It’s worth comparing quotes from multiple companies to see if you can find a better deal. At The Overmyer Insurance Agency, we make it easy for you to compare different company homeowners insurance policies. We partner with many insurance companies to help you find the most competitive rates without sacrificing or reducing your home insurance coverage.

​

2. Bundle Your Policies

​

Many insurers offer discounts if you bundle your home and auto insurance. This can provide significant savings and simplify your billing process. Often, you will see a 25% reduction in your overall costs if you combine or bundle your auto, homeowners, and umbrella insurance coverage with the same company.

​

3. Increase Your Deductible

​

Opting for a higher deductible can lower your premium. However, be sure you have enough savings set aside to cover the deductible if you need to file a claim. 

​

It’s important to get a quote to increase your deductibles first to make sure the cost savings outweigh any potential future claims. You don’t want to increase your deductibles just to have a claim in the near future, which could potentially offset any savings you may have gotten by raising your deductible.

​

4. Improve Your Home’s Safety Features

​

Installing a home central station security system, smoke detectors, backup generators, or a backup sump pump system can make your home less risky to insure, potentially lowering your premium. To make sure you are getting all the appropriate discounts, you should reach out to your agent and send the documentation to include the discounts on your policy. Some of the documentation may include:

​

• Central station burglar and fire alarm certificates

• Receipts/Invoices to prove the safety measures have been implemented in your home

• Photo or video of the safety systems that had been installed.

​

5. Home renovations, repairs or upgrades

​

If you have an older home, replacing your roof, furnace, hot water heater, or electrical system can help lower your home insurance costs.  

​

These renovations and upgrades can also be an underwriting eligibility factor. The better condition your home is in, the broader the range of companies you have to choose from when quoting for competing home insurance rates. For example, insurance companies regularly use roof age as an underwriting eligibility factor. Additionally, if you have a new roof, furnace, or water heater, this can add discounts to help lower your homeowners insurance costs.

​

6. Review Your Coverage Regularly

​

Your insurance needs may change over time. Regularly reviewing your policy ensures you’re not overinsured or underinsured. If you’ve made upgrades or changes to your home, be sure to let your insurer know, as this could affect your replacement cost coverage.

​

At the Overmyer Insurance Agency, we make it a regular practice to proactively reach out to our clients to ensure their homeowners insurance coverage is sufficient.

 

Understanding How New Jersey Compares

​

Compared to other states, New Jersey’s homeowners insurance rates remain moderate. However, the state’s unique factprs—such as wind and hurricane risks—set it apart from inland areas.

​

Average Cost of Homeowners Insurance in NJ

​

As of 2024, the average cost of homeowners insurance in New Jersey ranges from $1,100 to $1,500 annually for a home valued between $500,000 and $1,000,000. While this is higher than the national average, it reflects the state’s increased exposure to weather-related risks and high property values.

​

However, this will vary from home to home. Factors such as location, home size, construction materials, and coverage are needed to protect your home and assets sufficiently.

 

Why Work with The Overmyer Insurance Agency?

​

Navigating the complexities of homeowners insurance in NJ can be overwhelming, especially when rates are on the rise. At The Overmyer Insurance Agency, we pride ourselves on offering personalized service and expert guidance to help you find the right coverage for your needs.

​

What Sets Us Apart

​

• Local Expertise: Based in Cranford, NJ, we understand the unique risks and requirements of New Jersey homeowners.

• Wide Carrier Network: We work with multiple insurance providers to ensure you get the most competitive rates.

• Customized Solutions: We tailor your policy to your specific home and needs, ensuring you have the right coverage at a competitive cost.

 

The Bottom Line:

​

So, did NJ homeowners insurance go up? Yes, it did—but understanding the reasons behind the increase and taking proactive steps can help you manage costs effectively.

If you’re feeling overwhelmed or unsure about your current policy, we’re here to help. Contact The Overmyer Insurance Agency today for a free consultation, and let us guide you to the best insurance solutions for your New Jersey home.

​

Phone: 908-476-8685

Email: support@oianow.com

​